Full Description
Wesley Hohfeld is known the world over as the legal theorist who famously developed a taxonomy of legal concepts. His contributions to legal thinking have stood the test of time, remaining relevant nearly a century after they were first published. Yet, little systematic attention has been devoted to exploring the full significance of his work. Beginning with a lucid, annotated version of Hohfeld's most important article, this volume is the first to offer a comprehensive look at the scope, significance, reach, intricacies, and shortcomings of Hohfeld's work. Featuring insights from leading legal thinkers, the book also contains many of Hohfeld's previously unseen personal papers, shedding new light on the complex motivations behind Hohfeld's projects. Together, these selected papers and original essays reveal a portrait of a multifaceted and ambitious intellectual who did not live long enough to see the impact of his ideas on the study of law.
Contents
Introduction Shyamkrishna Balganesh, Ted Sichelman and Henry E. Smith; Some fundamental legal conceptions as applied in judicial reasoning Ted Sichelman; Selected personal papers of Wesley N. Hohfeld Ted Sichelman; Part I. Philosophy of Jural Relations: 1. Hohfeld on legal language Frederick Schauer; 2. Rights correlativity David Frydrych; 3. Hohfeld and rules Andrew Halpin; 4. Logic and the life of the law (professor): A logocratic lesson from hohfeld Scott Brewer; Part II. Hohfeld and Property: 5. Property's building blocks: Hohfeld in Europe and beyond Anna di Robilant and Talha Syed; 6. The in rem/in personam distinction and conceptual partitioning for persistence Shyamkrishna Balganesh and Leo Katz; 7. Hohfeld and the theory of in rem rights: An attempted mediation Christopher M. Newman; Part III. Hohfeld and Equity: 8. Hohfeld's equity J E Penner; 9. The essential nature of trusts and other equitable interests: Two and half cheers for Hohfeld Ben McFarlane; 10. General and particular jural relations Emily Sherwin; Part IV. Hohfeldian Complexities: 11. Very tight 'bundles of sticks': Hohfeld's complex jural relations Ted Sichelman; 12. Hohfeldian analysis and the separation of rights and powers John C. P. Goldberg and Benjamin C. Zipurskyi; 13. Immunity rules John Harrison; 14. Scaling up legal relations Andrew S. Gold and Henry E. Smith; Part V. Hohfeld and Society: 15. Hohfeldian analysis, liberalism and adjudication (some tensions) Pierre Schlag; 16. The contingent politics of legal formalism Aditi Bagchi; 17. Religious liberty & public accommodations: What would Hohfeld say? Joseph William Singer; 18. Wesley Newcomb Hohfeld, on the difficulty of becoming a law professor John Henry Schlegel.
