Description
Learn to plan, conduct, or update a systematic review of qualitative evidence
Qualitative Evidence Syntheses (QESs) are an increasingly important type of systematic review and a valuable tool for global and local decision-making. Their value as a method for systematically bringing together, assessing and synthesizing qualitative research has made them a crucial part of the industry-standard Cochrane and Campbell Reviews. There is an urgent and as-of-yet unmet need for a QES handbook which equips Cochrane and Campbell review authors with the most appropriate tools, processes, and methods required to conduct robust and trusted QESs.
The Cochrane-Campbell Handbook for Qualitative Evidence Synthesis meets this need with a comprehensive, step-by-step guide to conducting Cochrane and Campbell-standard QES. Informed by the knowledge and experience of the Cochrane Qualitative and Implementation Methods Group (QIMG) and members of the Campbell Methods Group, the Cochrane-Campbell Handbook arms review authors with everything they need to conduct qualitative evidence syntheses. The Handbook includes new guidance and evidence-informed tools that make a critical contribution to the ever more important field of evidence synthesis.
Cochrane-Campbell Handbook for Qualitative Evidence Synthesis readers will also find:
- Peer-reviewed chapters covering key review processes and methods written by a group of highly experienced qualitative and mixed methods researchers and review authors
- Detailed discussion of additional topics including integrating the findings of a QES with an intervention effects review, public and professional involvement in QESs, equity, diversity and inclusion, reflexivity, how to peer review and report a QES
- Valuable information and guidance to complement Cochrane’s robust training program (https://training.cochrane.org)
The Cochrane-Campbell Handbook for Qualitative Evidence Synthesis is ideal for researchers and reviewers, including trainers, Cochrane and Campbell editors, guideline groups, including WHO and NICE, and all those who wish to understand, critique or use systematic reviews which include qualitative evidence.
Table of Contents
List of Contributors xiii
Foreword xv
Preface xvii
Acknowledgements xxi
Part One Getting started 1
1 Starting a qualitative evidence synthesis 3
1.1 Introduction 3
1.2 Why do a qualitative evidence synthesis? 4
1.3 What questions can a qualitative evidence synthesis address? 5\
1.4 Equity, diversity and inclusion 6
1.5 Who should undertake a QES? 7
1.6 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 8
1.7 What types of qualitative evidence and data can be used? 8
1.8 Registering a title 9
1.9 Protocol development 9
1.10 Review integrity and information management 10
1.11 Reflexivity in QES 12
1.12 Chapter information 13
Part Two Core stages of a qualitative evidence synthesis 15
2 Defining the review scope and formulating a review question 17
2.1 Introduction 17
2.2 Moving from a review topic to a review question 18
2.3 What makes a good review question? 19
2.4 Types of questions addressed by a QES 20
2.5 Defining the scope of a review question 25
2.6 Refining the question(s) 26
2.7 Frameworks for question formulation 27
2.8 Taxonomies, frameworks and logic models 30
2.9 Reporting the review question 31
2.10 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 32
2.11 Equity, diversity and inclusion 33
2.12 Reflexivity 34
2.13 Chapter information 35
3 Selecting and using theory 41
3.1 Introduction 41
3.2 What is theory? 42
3.3 The role of theory in qualitative evidence syntheses 45
3.4 How to use theory in systematic reviews 48
3.5 Synthesising theories 54
3.6 Equity, diversity and inclusion 55
3.7 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 56
3.8 Reflexivity 56
3.9 Chapter information 56
4 Developing and using logic models 59
4.1 Introduction 59
4.2 What is a logic model? 60
4.3 Elements of a logic model and considerations for qualitative evidence syntheses 61
4.4 Depicting causality and intervention complexity within logic models supporting qualitative evidence synthesis 66
4.5 The role of logic models at different stages of systematic reviews 70
4.6 Developing and using logic models for systematic reviews 73
4.7 Engaging and involving of diverse perspectives 78
4.8 Equity, diversity and inclusion 78
4.9 Reflexivity 79
4.10 Chapter information 80
5 Searching for and identifying studies 85
5.1 Introduction 85
5.2 General issues 86
5.3 Search procedures 88
5.4 Planning the search 94
5.5 Sources to search 95
5.6 Citation and related-item searches 99
5.7 Screening and selecting studies 99
5.8 Machine learning and qualitative research 99
5.9 Documenting and reporting the searching and screening process 101
5.10 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 102
5.11 Equity, diversity and inclusion 102
5.12 Reflexivity 102
5.13 Chapter information 103
6 Selecting studies and sampling 109
6.1 Introduction 109
6.2 Selecting studies for inclusion 111
6.3 Software support for selecting studies 121
6.4 Steps once included studies are identified 123
6.5 Getting started with purposive sampling from studies that meet the inclusion criteria 126
6.6 Reporting study selection and sampling 131
6.7 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 135
6.8 Equity, diversity and inclusion 135
6.9 Reflexivity 135
6.10 Chapter information 136
7 Assessing methodological strengths and limitations of qualitative studies 141
7.1 Introduction 141
7.2 Quality concepts and criteria in qualitative research 144
7.3 Introducing CAMELOT as a tool for assessing methodological limitations 146
7.4 Choosing a tool to assess methodological strengths and limitations 149
7.5 General considerations for assessing methodological strengths and limitations of studies using tools 151
7.6 Using assessments of methodological limitations in sensitivity analyses to test the robustness of findings 159
7.7 Additional guidance for different study designs 159
7.8 Moving from single studies to synthesised findings and applying GRADE-CERQual 160
7.9 Reflexivity 160
7.10 Equity, diversity and inclusion 161
7.11 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 161
7.12 Chapter information 161
8 Selecting a method of synthesis and collecting relevant data 165
8.1 Introduction 165
8.2 Overview of synthesis methods 166
8.3 Understanding similarities and differences in synthesis methods 170
8.4 Selecting a method of synthesis 177
8.5 Collecting data for synthesis 179
8.6 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 183
8.7 Equity, diversity and inclusion 183
8.8 Reflexivity 184
8.9 Chapter information 185
Part Three Core methods for synthesis 189
9 Conducting a framework synthesis 191
9.1 Introduction 191
9.2 Origins and overview of framework approaches 192
9.3 Considerations when selecting framework synthesis 193
9.4 Stages of framework synthesis 195
9.5 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 205
9.6 Equity, diversity and inclusion 206
9.7 Reflexivity 206
9.8 Chapter information 207
10 Conducting a thematic synthesis 213
10.1 Introduction 213
10.2 Development of thematic synthesis 214
10.3 Key features 216
10.4 Stages of thematic synthesis 217
10.5 Context and rigour in thematic synthesis 229
10.6 Reporting the synthesis 232
10.7 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 234
10.8 Equity, diversity and inclusion 236
10.9 Reflexivity 237
10.10 Chapter information 237
11 Conducting a meta-ethnography 243
11.1 Introduction 243
11.2 Development of meta-ethnography 244
11.3 When to use meta-ethnography 245
11.4 Phases of meta-ethnography 246
11.5 Reflexivity 258
11.6 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 258
11.7 Equity, diversity and inclusion 259
11.8 Reporting guidance 260
11.9 Chapter information 260
12 Using visual methods to support synthesis 265
12.1 Introduction 265
12.2 Overview of visual methods and their uses 266
12.3 Considerations when selecting a visual method to support the synthesis 266
12.4 Example of the use of visual methods to support the development of a meta-ethnography 271
12.5 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 287
12.6 Equity, diversity and inclusion 287
12.7 Reflexivity 287
12.8 Chapter information 288
13 Assessing confidence in the evidence using the GRADE-CERQual approach 291
13.1 Introduction 291
13.2 What is confidence in the evidence in relation to findings from a QES? 292
13.3 The GRADE-CERQual approach 293
13.4 Applying GRADE-CERQual 295
13.5 Using GRADE-CERQual assessments to inform the 'implications for research' section of a QES 310
13.6 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 310
13.7 Equity, diversity and inclusion 311
13.8 Reflexivity 311
13.9 Chapter information 312
14 Integrating qualitative and quantitative evidence 317
14.1 Introduction 318
14.2 Overview of mixed-methods systematic reviews and approaches for integrating qualitative and quantitative evidence 319
14.3 Approaches for integrating QES and intervention effects evidence by 'comparing' 323
14.4 Approaches for integrating QES and intervention effects evidence by 'connection' 330
14.5 Determining which integration approach to use 337
14.6 Relevance and rigour 340
14.7 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 340
14.8 Equity, diversity and inclusion 341
14.9 Reflexivity 341
14.10 Chapter information 342
Part Four Non-core methods 347
15 Conducting time-sensitive reviews 349
15.1 Introduction 349
15.2 Types of time-sensitive QESs and considerations for use 350
15.3 Time-saving processes and procedures 352
15.4 Rapid QES 356
15.5 QES updates 359
15.6 Living QES 364
15.7 Overviews of QESs 366
15.8 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 371
15.9 Equality, diversity and inclusion 371
15.10 Reflexivity 371
15.11 Chapter information 372
16 Conducting a realist synthesis 377
16.1 Introduction 377
16.2 Formulation of review 378
16.3 Identification of evidence for theory generation, testing and refinement 387
16.4 Appraisal of evidence 389
16.5 Synthesis and interpretation of evidence 391
16.6 Strengths, limitations and future developments of realist synthesis 395
16.7 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 396
16.8 Equity, diversity and inclusion 397
16.9 Reflexivity 397
16.10 Chapter information 398
17 Reviewing diverse types of implementation evidence 405
17.1 Introduction 405
17.2 Formulation of review 409
17.3 Identification of evidence 419
17.4 Appraisal of evidence 422
17.5 Data extraction and synthesis 425
17.6 Reflexivity 428
17.7 Chapter information 430
18 Conducting a qualitative comparative analysis 435
18.1 Introduction 435
18.2 What is QCA? 436
18.3 Key features of QCA and its suitability for understanding intervention complexity 437
18.4 Formulation of the review 443
18.5 Identification of evidence 445
18.6 Appraisal of evidence 447
18.7 Synthesis of evidence 448
18.8 Practicalities of carrying out QCA in a review 461
18.9 The nature of evidence offered by QCA 464
18.10 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 464
18.11 Equity, diversity and inclusion 465
18.12 Reflexivity 465
18.13 Chapter information 465
19 Introducing meta-narrative reviews, critical interpretive synthesis and meta-aggregation 471
19.1 Introduction 471
19.2 Meta-narrative reviews 472
19.3 Critical interpretive synthesis 480
19.4 Meta-aggregation 486
19.5 Synthesis and interpretation of evidence 487
19.6 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 489
19.7 Equity, diversity and inclusion 490
19.8 Reflexivity 490
Part Five Reporting and peer review 493
20 Reporting a protocol and a review 495
20.1 Introduction 495
20.2 Cochrane RevMan template for QES 497
20.3 Reporting a QES or a mixed-methods review with a QES component 498
20.4 Reporting realist, meta-narrative and intervention implementation reviews 502
20.5 Reporting updates, overviews and living of QES reviews 503
20.6 What does a well-reported QES look like? 505
20.7 Role of other systematic review software in reporting a QES 506
20.8 Reflexivity 506
20.9 Engaging and involving diverse perspectives 507
20.10 Equity, diversity and inclusion 508
20.11 Chapter information 509
21 Peer reviewing a protocol and a review 513
21.1 Introduction 513
21.2 The purpose of peer review and the role of peer reviewers 514
21.3 Types of peer review 515
21.4 The peer review process 515
21.5 How to peer review 520
21.6 Addressing peer reviewer comments 529
21.7 Chapter information 530
References 530
Index 533
-
- 洋書電子書籍
- オックスフォード版 会社法とガバナンス…
-
- 洋書電子書籍
-
イスラエルと歴史の魅惑
Isra…
-
- 洋書電子書籍
-
教育改革国際ハンドブック・第3集
-
- 洋書電子書籍
- Model-Based Safety …



