Full Description
The Legal Pluralism of Heritage: Restitution and the Normative Knowledge of Communities of Origin explores one of the most urgent debates in international cultural heritage law today: the role of Indigenous laws and local norms about material culture in the restitution process.
In an era of rising claims for restitution, this book examines how diverse legal and normative orders engage with communities seeking the return of cultural objects held in museums, private collections, and institutions worldwide. It argues that restitution processes need to consider the normative knowledge of communities of origin. Moving beyond conventional legal analysis, the volume includes theoretical interventions and case studies from (international) law, anthropology, archaeology, history, museum studies, art history and Indigenous legal studies, and from all five continents. It offers a new framework for understanding restitution not merely as a legal process, but as a dialogue between legal systems and the knowledge traditions of the communities to whom heritage belongs.
Timely and thought-provoking, this book is an essential resource for researchers and practitioners in international law, legal history, historical anthropology, and cultural heritage studies.
Contents
1. Introduction - Legal Pluralism of Heritage: Towards a New Approach to Cultural Heritage Law
Part I: Constellations of Legal Pluralism and Cultural Heritage
2. Confronting the Complex Ontologies of Colonial Objects: Towards Greater Epistemic Pluralism
3. Taking Indigenous Intellectual Property Law Seriously as Law
4. Asking Better Provenance Questions? Cultural Heritage, Legal Pluralism, and the 'Other'
Part II: (De)Constructing Institutions of Normative Knowledge
5. Barriers to the Homecoming of Cultural Heritage for Indigenous LGBTQIA+ Peoples: Welcoming the Unwelcome Indigenous-Rainbow 'Other'
6. Colonial Collections and the Translocation of Belongings: The Long Duration of German Debates on Ownership of Cultural Heritage
7. Collecting at a Colonial Museum: A Case Study of the Raffles Museum in Singapore, 1874-1942
8. Colliding Regimes of Normativity at Tell Halaf: The Ottoman Antiquities Law's Implementation between Local Customs and Foreign Intervention
Part III: Conflicting Normativities and Restitution
9. And What about Internal Restitutions? Legal Aspects of the Return of Archaeological Artefacts to Indigenous Peoples
10. Legal Pluralism in the Criminal Courtroom: Reclaiming Indigenous Material Culture
11. Applying Fijian Vanua Research Frameworks for Repatriation in Museums: An Indigenous iTaukei Perspective
Part IV: Integrating Pluralism: Thinking about Legal Remedies
12. Imagining a Pluriversal Cultural Heritage Law
13. Rupture and Continuity: The Ambivalence of the State Succession Law for Material Culture during Decolonization
14. Legal Pluralism and the Restitution of Indigenous Cultural Property in Latin America: Formalist and Humanist Perspectives
15. Returning Emwin Arre to The Benin Kingdom: Using Traditional Customary Laws as a Path Towards Regional Restitution Policies in Nigeria
16. Afterword



